Love Island USA Fans Accuse Show of Being Rigged After Shocking Elimination of Hannah & Jeremiah

Love Island USA Fans Cry “Rigged!” Over Hannah & Jeremiah Dumping

Love Island USA sent shockwaves through its viewer base on June 22, 2025, when fan-favorites Hannah Fields and Jeremiah Brown were dumped from the villa in an unexpected twist. This double elimination, happening just before the Casa Amor phase, sparked instant backlash—with viewers flooding social media, accusing the voting process of being manipulated 

🧩 How the Vote Unfolded

1. America’s Vote
   U.S. viewers cast votes for their favorite male and female islanders. The bottom three—Jeremiah, Austin Shepard, Pepe Garcia (men), and Hannah, Iris Kendall, Amaya Espinal (women)—were placed at risk.

2. Cast Decision
   The remaining islanders decided who to eliminate: the girls picked to send home Hannah, and the boys chose Jeremiah .

The combo of a public vote followed by a cast voting off its own shocked fans—and it felt like a bait-and-switch.

😡 Social Media Explodes

Viewers took to X (formerly Twitter), Facebook, TikTok, and Reddit to vent:

• Y’all rigging votes and it’s not fun to watch anymore

• Production rigged this vote because no way that many people voted for Huda

• JEREMIAH???? OVER AUSTIN?????????? 

🔍 Why Fans Think It’s Rigged

1. App Outages
   Many fan voters reported hitting a “JSON PARSE error” during the vote window, believing the app crashed and skewed results .

2. Narrative Control
   Critics allege producers are manipulating outcomes—Huda Mustafa remained safe despite polarizing behavior, which fans argue is unrealistic in a fair vote .

3. Cast Voting Power
   Shifting elimination control to cast members, especially when favorites are affected, raised red flags: fans say it subverts the purpose of a U.S. vote .

4. Suspicious Alliances
   Viewers also noted pre-show ties: Ace Greene and Chelley Bissainthe reportedly had an online friendship dating back to 2022—casting doubt on authenticity .

🙇 What Cast Reactions Reveal

Inside the villa, the tension was palpable. Friends cried, alliances were scrutinized:

• Jeremiah’s betrayal: The boys openly debated choosing between him, Austin, and Pepe—leading to fans accusing them of jealousy and obvious manipulation .

• Girls' tough call: Hannah’s exit prompted strong emotions—fans questioned why more emotionally complex islanders like Iris or Amaya didn’t go instead .

🎭 Fan Fallout & Future of the Season

• Many fans said they might ditch the show: “I don’t even wanna watch anymore,” echoed multiple times .

• Critics worry that scripted drama and manipulated arcs risk eroding the audience's trust.

🔄 The Producers’ Play: Casa Amor & Ratings

Despite the uproar, the show presses on—Episode 19 kicks off Casa Amor, splitting original couples and adding ten new bombshells . It’s classic Love Island: tension, surprise, and opportunity. Could this risky storyline be a bold production gamble to boost ratings—and hold viewers hostage with manufactured scandal?

❓ Final Thoughts

Is Love Island USA Season 7 truly rigged—or is it classic reality TV cup-and-ball trickery? Viewers are split: